This book is imperfect (I have critiques) but it is definitely on my list of “books I’ll recommend to someone.” If that sounds like a contradiction – well, you can enjoy something that is imperfect despite it’s imperfections.
Here, There be Dragons is, at it’s core, a fun adventure novel. I thought it was a little predictable, but it is a fun twist on the “fairy tale” genre. It fits into the trend of re-examining the classic tales and/or referencing them without expecting them to be some kind of “TRUTH.”
I listened to this book, and the reader of the audiobook (James Langton) did a great job with the accents and character voices without making them take over the story. Especially in books where the author didn’t plan out audio (and so made sure to say “Said John.” type things) it helps for the narrator to have voices.
The biggest critique I have in this book is some (I suspect unintended) sexism. There is one female character of note. Oh, I think one of the 3-fates might be the most memorable but she had one scene versus the woman who was in the book the entire time. I don’t think (or at least I’m going to assume it) James Owen meant to be sexist, I just think he assumed his primary audience would be young boys and they would want male protagonists. There isn’t really a romance plot-line, which is more common in male-marketed fantasy (female-marketed fantasy is critiqued if they don’t have a romance plot…)
I DO like the way James Owen tackled myths and their interactions. I like how he pointed out the “3 women controlling fate” has different names in different myths – and there similarities and differences and how they can be handled.
It is worth getting the end and seeing the twist he included. I can’t say I “saw it coming” but I had been suspicious of something from pretty early in the book and when the twist happened I was able to think “Ha! I knew that thing I’d noticed couldn’t be an an accident! THAT’S what he was doing with it. Nice.”
It is absolutely worth the read, but it isn’t a book I would say “your kid needs to read this to grow up” (like I did with Alanna). I don’t know that I would even say “it will make you think” – I don’t know that it would make an adult think (I kind of home not). BUT, it was a fun romping adventure that made me want to find out how they’d reach the end. It is one of the better “twisted fairy tale” stories I think I’ve seen lately and for that alone, I’d give it about a 3/5 stars. Good, not brilliant.